8 Sept 2010

marriage as an answer

If our relational lives were put on a linear scale from worst situation to best I'm sure it would start with isolation and end in community. Marriage would be somewhere in the middle. This has been one of the most common conversations I've had with those in my life of late. The question keeps appearing, 'What would you rather, marriage or community?' Too many answer with the latter. Strange? Now, I must add that most of these friends are ones that have experienced living in community at some point. Most of them currently living in what people have told me is called the 'real world.' So they reminisce the days surrounded in company much larger than themselves.

We live in a grossly emphasized individualistic society. I comprehended it better after living in the more communal Asia. Dr. Perry is so correct in describing our society as relationally impoverished. And we are just supposed to live with this reality? This 'real life?' It is much harder to accept when one has lived in community. You come to realize it is the greatest way of living.

I write this as both an emotional response to current circumstances and as a simple observation of how people see reality. I almost cannot blame my friends anymore for getting married and preoccupying their time and energy into this one person. How does one in a society that pushes individuals to be their own at a very young age expect humans to deal? The reality is that we can't do life alone. Not well. And since communities rarely exist in our culture marriage is an attractive option for coping with loneliness.
What I find most interesting, though, is that once the couple gets married they still face loneliness.. and then what? We must contend that marriage does not end loneliness and here I must say that nothing will. It is the human condition that we suffer with this gnawing feeling of desire, longing and loss - but I think we can learn to do it well and/or better (living in the tension - resting in tension!) Perhaps we could rest in the tension more gracefully when knowing we sit with a dozen or so people who are experiencing the same.. who share the same existence. The problem then is not that marriage exists, or that it is not good, but that we are taught it is the answer.

I still find marriage as an answer too largely limited. I believe we need dialogue and love beyond the borders of two. In fact I have many married friends who are still in search of the community they once knew. There is something so beautiful about having deep friendships for years upon years. Having friends who prove to be committed to you over time and all without a contract. I have found the greatest happiness in my life has been when living in community and surrounded by those I share deep and meaningful relationships with - men and women, young and old - learning from their experiences and perspectives, growing with them. So far a boyfriend has not exceeded this joy, freedom and love. But this is just my experience. The venting comes when I wish others thought so. You see, I'm not in community now and I long for it. Why do not others? Oh for the day when we are desperate, not for a man or woman but for people to share life with!

8 comments:

Unknown said...

Roommate, I agree. One thing that I find annoying is not only the fact that people don't long for it (which is only because they are ignorant to the joys it brings), but that when you talk about it, they immediately associate it with some sort of cult. The whole idea of living in community is so far removed from Western culture.

Steph said...

that is such a sad state of affairs. it reveals many things among which where our values lie and what we are taught. north america is definitely lacking in a social mindset. we would rather play the game of capitalism and individualize ourselves more in order to grow our own kingdoms and wealth.
let's move to... asia... mm.. but i don't want to move there.. (and they're doing the same thing..)
let's move to winnipeg...
or let's just change the world. :)

Unknown said...

:)

Unknown said...

thanks for sharing this steph. community is something i long for as well, and i do believe it is something inherent to living in light of the kingdom. i believe this is also the story told in scripture. it's something i always find myself reflecting upon, i hope it's okay if i share a couple of thoughts. i don't comment much on blogs but i assume this is what they're for.
i'm assuming here that fundamental to our humanity is other people, for we are not truly human if we are alone. i think this is told in scripture, for example in genesis 2 when God notes that it is not good for man to be alone. inherent in us is the need for other people - humanity is bound up together so that to hurt another is to hurt yourself and to speak the word into another is in effect to validate it in yourself.
marriage, which you've mentioned, is certainly beautiful and irreplaceable in its covenantal nature of two lives conjoined, even perhaps seen in the context of a community, but it cannot be seen as to replace community.
as a prof of mine, victor shepherd, put it, he [shepherd] is not everything that is male to his wife, nor is she everything female to him. in other words, community must extend beyond marriage.
to place in marriage the expectations that community exists to meet simultaneously exhausts marriages, in effect cheapening them, and robs communities. we need to have a greater (theologically based perhaps?) understanding of both marriage and community, specifically how the exist in the context of one another.
-richard

curtis said...

Wonderful thoughts my friend. I wholeheartedly agree! I leave you with the thoughts of Robert Joustra of Comment Magazine: "Marriage is not the lifelong attraction of two people, but a call of two people to witness to God's love. The real mystery is not how their love helps them discover God, but how God's love for them helps them discover each other."

"For in our rush to fill the voids, the emptiness and the meaninglessness of our materialist lives, we have retreated to the vocation of marriage and family as a final stronghold in which to find intimacy and communion. Ironically - and it is an unhappy irony - when we make the family our focus, our families are in more danger, collapsing under the weight of impossibly unmet emotional expectations."

In community I find my true identity for it is there that love as God sees it can be learned and lived.

Steph said...

thanks richard! i like your thoughts. i appreciate what your prof said. i think too often we're looking for a man (or woman) to somehow fill all the gaps in our lives... as you said, this pressure and expectation is far too large to place on one person. one must extent their relationships!
would you like to write a book on a more theologically based view on marriage and community? :) i'd buy a copy!

curtis, great quotes! thanks for sharing. i'm loving that married people are responding to this blog. it affirms me. :)

and again.. so glad my community is continually extended.. and i consider you part of it.

joey armstrong said...

great post steph... love your thoughts. i feel i am often torn by longing for community and stubbornly wanting my individuality. maybe because i don't feel like i really 'fit' in any communities i've been a part of or would 'fit' in communities i see from a distance and want to be a part of. or maybe i am stuck on always feeling loneliness even when i am 'in community,' and wanting it to go away, but like you said it's our human condition. sometimes i find myself wanting community and waiting for it to just happen, when i know its probably not going to happen that way, and maybe i have to start making community instead. maybe there are others out there who are wanting it as well, but are waiting too, instead of being pro-active. so many things to think about! thanks for the inspiration...

Steph said...

thanks for your thoughts joey. i share most of them! community is not easy either.. to cultivate or to exist whithin. life is hard. :) but i'd rather not live it alone. i do hope you find if but a small community where you are!